Beauty’s daigou addiction comes with a $210 million price tag

Earlier this month, The Estée Lauder Companies agreed to a proposed $210 million settlement to resolve claims from investors who alleged the company concealed the extent of its reliance on China’s daigou trade during the Covid-19 pandemic. The company denied wrongdoing, and said insurance would cover a portion of the settlement costs. Plaintiffs argued that sales growth, particularly through Hainan’s duty-free channels, had become dangerously dependent on gray-market reseller networks — and that the company concealed the damage when China launched a crackdown on daigou activity in January 2022. When the structure unraveled, it wiped $8.7 billion from the company’s market value. For years, daigou — parallel importers who undercut retail prices — occupied an unusual position within China’s luxury and beauty market. Officially, it was a gray market. Unofficially, it functioned as one of the industry’s most efficient distribution systems — built on a simple formula: buy through lower-priced channels such as airport duty-free shops, overseas retailers and Hainan’s tax-free programs, then resell into mainland China through social networks and independent storefronts. Why China’s ‘daigou’ economy rewrote luxury beauty rules The appeal was straightforward. Price gaps created instant demand. Imported beauty products sold through official Chinese channels frequently carried substantial premiums over duty-free pricing — and in prestige skincare, where repeat purchasing and product authenticity both matter, the economics worked particularly well. Take Estée Lauder’s bestselling Advanced Night Repair serum. At the height of the daigou boom, unofficial channels sold it for roughly 4-5 RMB ($0.60-$0.75) per milliliter — less than half the approximately 9.8 RMB per milliliter listed on the brand’s official Tmall flagship. Over time, that pricing gap shaped consumer perception in ways that proved difficult to reverse. Prestige beauty products were not overpriced, shoppers reasoned — they simply were not worth buying at full price. Once consumers are conditioned to permanent discounting, price architecture loses credibility. For years, few companies had much incentive to challenge any of this. Daigou moved inventory quickly, penetrated lower-tier markets where brands lacked physical infrastructure, and created a form of social commerce long before livestream retail became mainstream. More importantly, it produced growth. How Hainan duty-free became beauty’s hidden growth engine During the pandemic, that growth accelerated sharply. When international travel collapsed, Hainan emerged as one of the world’s most important beauty retail markets almost overnight. China expanded the island’s duty-free infrastructure as part of broader domestic consumption initiatives, and products originally intended for international travel retail flowed into Hainan instead — creating an enormous arbitrage opportunity. Bulk buyers and intermediary suppliers began purchasing inventory at scale before redistributing products through social commerce channels, private reseller groups and independent online stores. Hainan had become less a tourism story than a shadow logistics hub for China’s prestige beauty market. Estée Lauder was more exposed than most. Travel retail represented roughly 23% of company revenue in fiscal 2019, climbing to 29% by fiscal 2021. The contrast with peers was stark: L’Oréal’s travel retail business accounted for around 9% of its global sales in 2019 — less than half Estée Lauder’s share — and its broader business mix offered considerably more insulation. China’s ‘daigou’ crackdown exposed beauty’s demand illusion In January 2022, Chinese authorities launched anti-smuggling campaigns targeting daigou traders and duty-free resale activity, while platforms simultaneously tightened rules around Hainan-related gray-market sales. The impact moved quickly through Estée Lauder’s financial results. Fiscal 2023 revenue fell 10% — the first of three consecutive years of declining sales — with global travel retail down 34% organically, its share of total revenue falling from 27% to 20%. Management acknowledged on earnings calls that enforcement shifts around Hainan purchasing behavior were a contributing factor. For years, investors — and perhaps brands themselves — struggled to distinguish real demand from channel-driven demand. Daigou activity moved products, but movement did not necessarily indicate stronger consumer relationships, or healthier brand equity. The ecosystem functioned less like organic demand and more like an amplification mechanism built around pricing inefficiencies. In China, consumers no longer discover products through department store counters or travel retail channels. They find them through creators, social media communities, livestreaming platforms and peer recommendations. Distribution advantages matter less than cultural relevance. The challenge facing Estée Lauder now mirrors one facing global beauty more broadly: how to rebuild growth once the gray-market tailwind disappears. South Korea’s duty-free industry finds life after ‘daigou’ South Korea may offer an early glimpse of what happens next. For years, the country’s duty-free sector relied heavily on Chinese daigou traffic. Sales volumes looked enormous, but the economics were fragile. To attract reseller networks, operators paid high intermediary commissions that inflated revenue while compressing margins. The structure held as long as Chinese daigou demand kept expanding. Once pandemic disruptions, shifting tourism patterns and changing consumer behavior arrived simultaneously, those vulnerabilities became impossible to ignore. Now the recovery story looks markedly different. In Q1 2026, major Korean operators including Lotte, Shilla and Shinsegae reported improved profitability across the board. Lotte Duty Free posted sales of approximately $540 million, up 24% YoY, while operating profit more than doubled to roughly $22 million. Shilla’s duty-free division swung back to profit, with operating income of approximately $8.3 million after a loss in the same quarter a year earlier, as sales rose 7% to around $600 million. The customer profile also began changing. According to Korea Duty Free Shops Association data, foreign shopper traffic surpassed one million visitors in March 2026, recovering above a symbolic threshold for the first time in years. Yet sales growth no longer mirrored the explosive spending patterns of the daigou era. Rather than depending on a small number of high-volume buyers, retailers increasingly benefited from a broader base of ordinary travelers. During the daigou hayday, a small number of resellers could generate outsized transaction values, but operators often paid substantial commissions to maintain those relationships. Today, individual spending is lower: According to data from the Korea Duty Free Shops Association, average foreign visitor purchases reportedly fell from roughly $455 per person last year to about $355. Yet operators are increasingly viewing that decline as evidence of healthier demand rather than weaker demand, because customer concentration risk has eased and commission pressure has fallen. The duty-free industry is moving away from dependence on a small number of customers purchasing enormous volumes toward a larger number of travelers purchasing smaller amounts. Sales may look less spectacular than during the daigou boom, but the structure increasingly appears more sustainable.

Beauty’s ‘daigou’ reckoning arrives

Upgrade to Pro

Sectors

Insights

Company

Beauty’s ‘daigou’ reckoning arrives